On the morning of June 9, 2017, two service technicians and a second engineer were working in the auxiliary boiler room at the vessel's stern. The boilers had been restarted several times due to abnormal operations of the pressure safety valves. Despite attempts to troubleshoot the problem, the boilers continued to malfunction.
At approximately 07:38 a.m., boiler no. 1 catastrophically failed, filling the room with superheated steam. The failure resulted in severe burns and respiratory injuries to the crew members in the room. Tragically, the two service technicians and the second engineer succumbed to their injuries, while the blast also injured another crew member working outside the boiler room.
This fatal incident was a stark reminder of the risks associated with working in high-pressure environments like the boiler room, and it raised critical questions about the safety practices and protocols in place on the ship.
An investigation into the Norbe VIII incident revealed several contributing factors that led to the boiler failure. These factors highlight the complexity of managing high-risk equipment and the importance of adhering to strict maintenance protocols. Below are some of the critical findings:
One of the most significant factors that contributed to the incident was the malfunctioning of the pressure safety valves. These valves are designed to release pressure from the boiler if it exceeds the maximum permissible operating level. However, in this case, the valves opened at pressures much lower than the boiler’s operating pressure of 7.0 bars. This abnormality led to multiple shutdowns and restarts of the boiler, increasing the risk of failure.
Another contributing factor was a miscalibration of the boiler's pressure sensors. The service technicians responsible for maintaining the boilers had isolated the pressure safety valves based on an incorrect mental model. This miscalculation meant that the boilers were operating under unsafe conditions for extended periods, leading to a build-up of pressure that the sensors failed to detect accurately.
The investigation also highlighted a lack of clear safety protocols for handling the malfunctioning boilers. Despite numerous alarms and warnings from the ship’s engine room monitoring system, no immediate action was taken to shut down the boilers completely. This oversight and repeated restarting of the boilers created the perfect conditions for a catastrophic failure.
REad more: Biofuels: Can They Power the Shipping Industry's Green Revolution?
The Norbe VIII incident provides several valuable lessons for maritime professionals, particularly those involved in ship maintenance and operation. Understanding these lessons can help prevent similar tragedies in the future.
The incident underscores the importance of strict safety procedures when dealing with high-risk equipment. Boilers operate at high pressure and temperature and require rigorous maintenance and constant monitoring to ensure they function correctly. Deviating from established safety protocols, even in seemingly minor ways, can have disastrous consequences.
Training is vital in preventing incidents like the one aboard Norbe VIII. Ensuring that all crew members, exceptionally those responsible for high-risk equipment like boilers, are properly trained in safety protocols and emergency response procedures is critical. This training should also emphasize the importance of recognizing early warning signs, such as abnormal pressure readings or repeated equipment malfunctions.
One of the primary lessons from this case is the importance of regular maintenance and calibration of critical safety systems. In the case of the Norbe VIII, the pressure safety valves and sensors were not functioning correctly, likely due to a lack of proper maintenance. Regular checks and calibration of these systems are essential to ensure they operate as designed in an emergency.
The ability to communicate effectively during a crisis is another crucial lesson from this incident. The crew aboard Norbe VIII received multiple alarms and warnings before the boiler failure, but these were not acted upon promptly. Ensuring that crew members are trained to make quick and informed decisions in high-pressure situations can significantly reduce the risk of accidents.